CCSCE 2008 Review Form

CCSCE Review Form

Paper Title:

Paper Number:

Important: This form is being provided to help you review papers.
Please submit your reviews online. The online version may differ slightly.

About the Content:

1. Importance of the topic to Computing Education:
         ___ Very important     ___ Important     ___ Neutral     ___Not important     ___Irrelevant

2. Interest in the Topic/Timeliness:
         ___ Great              ___ Moderate              ___ Neutral             ___Little              ___ None

3. Originality of the paper:
        ___ Very Original    ___ Original    ___ Neutral    ___ Not Original    ___ Reinventing the Wheel

4. Technical Soundness and Accuracy of the paper:
         ___ Very Good          ___ Good          ___ Fair          ___ Poor          ___ Very Poor

Please explain your ratings for the content of the paper:

About the Presentation:

        Organization     ___ Very Good     ___ Good     ___ Fair     ___ Poor     ___ Very Poor

        Clarity                  ___ Very Good     ___ Good     ___ Fair     ___ Poor     ___ Very Poor

        Language             ___ Very Good     ___ Good     ___ Fair     ___ Poor     ___ Very Poor

Please explain your ratings for the presentation of the paper:

Your Recommendations:

Your recommendation for this paper is
         ___ Definitely Accept
         ___ Lean to Accept
         ___ Neutral
         ___ Lean to Reject
         ___ Definitely Reject

Please explain your recommendation for the paper:

Please rate your familiarity with the topic:
         ___ Very Knowledgeable
         ___ Knowledgeable
         ___ Not Knowledgeable

Comments to the Authors/Modifications if the paper is (conditionally) accepted:

Confidential Notes:
These notes will not be sent to the author. They will be viewed only by the Papers Chair.